Salary is a very personal thing, and most people don’t like to discuss it openly, especially men when it comes to their own pay. However, many people find themselves gossiping or comparing their salaries, talking about whether they feel underpaid for the amount of work they do, questioning why overtime pay isn’t compensated better, or even wondering if their employers are paying them fairly.
While not all employees engage in these discussions, some do talk about salaries—whether it’s their own or others—sometimes sparking debates in the workplace. From an employer or HR professional’s point of view, this type of conversation is often discouraged and may even be seen as counterproductive, but the question arises: Can employers legally restrict employees from discussing salaries?
The Legality of Salary Discussions in the Workplace
Under U.S. law, employers cannot legally prohibit employees from discussing their salaries. The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), which governs labor rights in the United States, grants employees the right to discuss their wages, working conditions, and other terms of employment without fear of retaliation. This law applies to both unionized and non-unionized workplaces, making it clear that employees are legally protected when it comes to open discussions about salary.
The purpose of the NLRA is to protect workers’ rights to collectively bargain and organize, and salary discussions are a vital part of this right. Employees who discuss their wages may share information about pay disparities or identify potential inequalities, which can ultimately lead to workplace improvements and fairer pay practices.
Employers, however, may still have policies that govern professional conduct in the workplace. For example, it is common for companies to discourage employees from discussing salaries during working hours or in public spaces within the office. These policies are usually aimed at maintaining a professional atmosphere and preventing negative morale or tension among employees. But, such policies must not be restrictive to the point of infringing upon an employee’s right to talk about their pay.
What Can Employers Do?
While employers cannot legally stop employees from discussing salaries altogether, there are steps they can take to manage these discussions in a productive way:
- Create Clear Pay Transparency Policies: Encourage an open conversation about compensation by establishing clear pay structures and salary bands. This way, employees know what to expect and feel more comfortable discussing their pay with one another without feeling uncomfortable or disgruntled.
- Provide Regular Pay Reviews and Raises: Regularly review salaries to ensure that employees feel their compensation is fair and competitive. If employees feel that their compensation is aligned with their performance and the market rate, they are less likely to feel the need to gossip or complain about it.
- Promote Professionalism in the Workplace: Employers can encourage a culture where salary discussions are handled professionally and outside of work hours. They might suggest that employees bring up pay concerns during private meetings with HR or their managers, rather than discussing them in open spaces like lunchrooms or break rooms.
- Train HR and Managers on Addressing Pay Discussions: If salary conversations do occur, HR professionals and managers should be trained on how to address them. They should aim to handle any grievances employees may have regarding pay and ensure that salary discussions do not turn into resentment or cause unnecessary divisions within the team.
If you are an HR professional looking to learn more about human resource topics from experts in the field, you can enroll in our upcoming HR webinars. These webinars not only provide valuable knowledge but also offer HRCI and SHRM credits, helping you take your career to the next level. Be sure to check out our Human Resource Webinar page, where you can find hundreds of HR webinars, both upcoming and on-demand.
Conclusion
While employers cannot legally restrict employees from discussing their salaries, it’s crucial for organizations to foster a culture of openness and fairness when it comes to compensation.
Rather than trying to restrict these conversations, employers should focus on providing transparent pay structures, maintaining fair and equitable pay practices, and addressing any concerns employees may have directly.
By doing so, employers can prevent the negative impacts of salary discussions, such as dissatisfaction or division, and promote a healthier and more collaborative work environment.
